Instagram Facebook Bloglovin Twitter Pinterest

EradiKate vs Peter Thomas Roth Sulfur Masks on Sensitive Skin

There is a reason two sulfur masks keep earning a permanent spot on my bathroom shelf. Both the Kate Somerville EradiKate Sulfur Mask and the Peter Thomas Roth Sulfur Mask promise a deep clean in a short window, and both cost enough that I don't want to be guessing which one my skin actually tolerates. I have used each across a stretch of flare-ups on skin that runs dry, stings easily and occasionally misbehaves with eczema. This is the head-to-head I wish I had before buying either pot. Learn more about Skincare Routine.

Sulfur itself is unfussy and old-fashioned, a mineral that has been sold over pharmacy counters for well over a century. In a mask it does two genuinely useful jobs: it soaks up excess oil without the mechanical scrubbing of a gritty scrub, and it has a mild antibacterial effect on the bacteria that thrive in a blocked pore. The catch is that it is a drying ingredient, and the gap between a helpful treatment and a wrecked barrier comes down to concentration, pH and how long you leave it sitting there. Learn more about Vanitysalad.com.

What follows covers what each formula contains, how the two behaved on compromised skin, where a sulfur mask fits into an Australian summer routine, and what they actually cost here. The short version is this: one is a gentler, niacinamide-buffered cream that treats and calms in the same step, while the other is a faster, sharper clarifying gel that asks considerably more of your face.

What sulfur actually does to a face

Sulfur is not a new arrival in skincare, and that is part of its appeal. Pharmacy shelves have carried sulfur soaps and sulfur powders for generations, mostly aimed at teenagers with oily foreheads and congested T-zones. The modern version comes in a nicer jar, but the principle is the same. Applied to skin, sulfur draws oil out of the surface and reduces the bacteria feeding on it, which is why a properly formulated sulfur mask can flatten an angry spot overnight without the sticky residue of a pore strip.

The other thing to understand is that sulfur does not exfoliate. It will not dissolve dead cells the way an acid does, and it will not physically scrub. It works on oil and bacteria, and it works best when the skin underneath is already reasonably calm. That distinction explains nearly every complaint I see about these masks: people expect a resurfacing result and get a drying one instead.

Application is simple but not optional in terms of care. You need clean, dry skin, a thin layer applied with clean fingers, and a timer. Most formulas want ten to fifteen minutes, no longer. Rinse with lukewarm water and pat dry, then follow with a plain moisturiser. Leaving either of these masks on for half an hour because the instructions felt vague is the single most common way I have seen people turn a treatment into a problem.

The Kate Somerville EradiKate Sulfur Mask, up close

The EradiKate Mask lists 10% sulfur alongside 5% niacinamide and 3% zinc PCA, and that supporting cast changes the character of the whole product considerably. Niacinamide is one of the better-evidenced ingredients for calming visible redness and supporting a compromised barrier, so the sulfur here is buffered rather than left to strip. Zinc PCA adds a little sebum regulation for the T-zone.

The texture is a thick, pale yellow cream that spreads without dragging and dries to a slightly tacky translucent film rather than a chalky white mask. It has a faint herbal scent that mostly fades after the rinse, though a trace lingers in the bathroom air for a few minutes. My application time was ten to fifteen minutes, and I rinsed it with a soft cloth rather than my fingers, which avoided the kind of scrubbing that turns a mask into an abrasive.

Afterwards, my skin did not feel tight. That is the difference I keep circling back to with this one. There was no squeaky, drawn-out feeling, no flaking in the days that followed, and my cheeks stayed comfortable while the chin, where I was treating a congested patch, looked smoother and less inflamed the next morning. Where I have old post-acne marks, the niacinamide seems to have done some quiet work over a few weeks of weekly use.

The things I like less: the pot format means more product touching fingers and hands, which is unhygienic and wasteful over a year of use, and this mask will not flatten a deep, white-headed spot the way the competing formula does. It also does nothing dramatic within a single use. It is the slower, quieter option, and if you want visible overnight change on an individual blemish, that is not what this jar is for.

The Peter Thomas Roth Sulfur Mask and its stronger hand

Peter Thomas Roth sells a range of clarifying treatments, and the sulfur one is the more aggressive sibling of the line-up. The formula pairs sulfur with salicylic acid in a thinner gel-cream that dries faster and harder, pulling the surface tight as it sets. There is also fragrance in the formula, which is noticeable for a good minute after application and lingers faintly on the skin.

On a genuine, active spot it works fast. I watched a whitehead on my jaw visibly shrink and flatten inside ten minutes, and the oil on my nose was noticeably reduced for the rest of the evening. That performance is the reason to buy it, and it is a real one: if your skin is oily and congested rather than dry and reactive, this mask will do more for you in one session than the EradiKate will do in a month.

The price of that punch is dryness. On the sides of my nose, where skin is naturally thinner, I got a tight, drawn feeling that took a while to soften, and on the chin I saw flaking within a day. The drying film also needs care at removal. It lifts easily, but if you let it dry past the recommended time, it can feel like it is welded on, and rubbing it off leaves the skin irritated rather than clean.

Used once every ten days on genuinely oily zones, this is an efficient product. Used twice a week on the whole face, it is a fast route to a compromised barrier. My rule, learned the hard way, is that it earns a spot treatment on the oily parts of my face and stays away from everything else.

How both behaved on reactive and eczema-prone skin

My first test of the Peter Thomas Roth mask was on a patch of chin eczema I thought had settled. Within about thirty seconds of application, the area started to burn in a way that felt different from the mask working. By morning the patch was red, flaking and angry again, and it took several days of bland moisturiser and no actives to settle. That reaction is the clearest argument for reading the ingredient list before you buy, because the sulfur and the salicylic acid together are a lot for skin that is already inflamed.

The EradiKate mask behaved far better on the same compromised skin. On a congested but closed spot on my jaw, it drew out oil, reduced the visible bump and left the surrounding skin calm. On the eczema-prone patch, I did not use it, because no active of any kind goes on broken skin in my routine, and the niacinamide support did not change that rule.

The routine I now follow is simple. Patch test on the inner arm for two days before a first facial use. Never on freshly shaved skin, because I have learned that lesson twice. No acids, retinoids or vitamin C on the same night. A bland moisturiser straight after, and sunscreen the following morning. If you want a second, more clinical read on how these formulas behave under controlled conditions, the beauty desk at Vanity Salad has published ingredient-level breakdowns of both masks that are worth reading alongside my own patchy results.

Both masks are fine for most skin types in moderation. Neither is fine for skin that is actively flaring. That distinction is less about brand and more about whether the skin barrier under the mask is intact.

Timing, routine placement and what it costs in Australia

I use a sulfur mask once a week, on a Sunday evening, when I am not going out and when there is no need to look presentable. It goes after cleansing and before moisturiser, and the following morning gets a proper SPF, which matters more here than almost anywhere else in the world. The UV index in Australia is brutal for much of the year, and a freshly treated face with thinned surface oil needs protection. If you are mapping out where this step actually belongs, I have written out my skincare routine in full on this site, including the order and the waiting times between steps.

Climate does the rest of the talking. In a Melbourne summer, air conditioning indoors and cold drinks in the sun outside mean skin that alternates between dehydration and humidity, and a weekly clarifying treatment fits that cycle well. Sydney's humidity and its chlorinated tap water are another matter: I rinse with lukewarm filtered water and give my face a pat with a damp cloth afterwards, because hard water leaves a mineral film that makes the post-mask skin feel tighter than it really is.

Pricing here does not match the US, and the Australian dollar swings enough that imported prices move with it. The EradiKate mask generally sits somewhere around AUD 80 to 110 depending on the retailer and whether it is part of a set, while the Peter Thomas Roth sulfur mask tends to land closer to AUD 55 to 75. Both are stocked at Sephora Australia and carried in Myer's beauty hall, with the PTR mask also turning up at Priceline and online marketplaces. Ulta Beauty still does not operate in Australia, so US shelf prices are not a useful guide.

Check the back of the tub before you commit. Australian labels use international ingredient naming, so the word you are looking for is printed as "Sulfur" even though nobody says it that way in a group chat. Fragrance is listed too, and it is more prominent in the Peter Thomas Roth formula than in the Kate Somerville one. Buying a smaller size first, or a pot you can dip into with a spatula rather than fingers, saves both money and product.

Which one suits which kind of skin

There are two ways to cut through the comparison, and which one you pick depends on whether your problem is oil or sensitivity.

If your skin is oily, congested and generally calm, the Peter Thomas Roth sulfur mask is the more satisfying product to own. Reach for the Peter Thomas Roth mask if:

If your skin runs dry, stings easily or flares with eczema, the gentler formulation is the wiser investment. Reach for the EradiKate mask if:

Between the two, the Kate Somerville EradiKate Sulfur Mask suits my own skin better by a comfortable margin, and it is the one I would repurchase. The Peter Thomas Roth formula is the more capable tool on oily, unbroken skin, and for a lot of people with combination skin it is the better buy. The decision comes down to what your skin is actually asking for: a deep reset on the oil, or a treatment that works without taking more than it gives.